Diskussjoni:Carmelo Caruana

Dan l-artiklu hemm bżonn jiġi wikifikat. Barra minn hekk, dan ukoll donnu meħud minn xi rivista ta' xi banda;

"bandist ma' diversi baned fosthom l-banda taghna."

Tony Sammut 07:24, 17 Lulju 2006 (UTC)

Do we have permission to use this text? 「ѕʀʟ·！」 16:02, 17 Lulju 2006 (UTC)

Carmelo Caruana on en.wikipedia

Hello, we recently had an article created on this same Maltese musician then rapidly deleted following a truncated discussion at w:en:Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carmelo Caruana. He was not viewed as sufficiently "notable" per our rules at w:en:Wikipedia:Notability (people). I was unfamiliar with this person but it seemed that he might be notable and I argued the article should be kept until someone more knowledgeable of Maltese topics and Maltese sources could review it. In any event, the article has been deleted but copies of the article and my comments can be found at:

• w:en:User:LukeCollins12/Carmelo Caruana (a user subpage belonging to the article's creator on en.wikipedia)
• w:en:User talk:LukeCollins12/Carmelo Caruana
• w:en:Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Carmelo Caruana

I noted that you have had an article on the same person at Carmelo Caruana for a number of years. It would seem that if this person is notable on mt. wikipedia, they should be notable on en.wikipedia. There is no requirement that our sources be in English only -- only that they be "reliable" (per our w:en:Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources rules).

Are there reliable sources in English or Maltese that would establish this person's notability and provide a basis for a reliable article?

Please feel free to respond positively or negatively on the deletion talk page at w:en:Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Carmelo Caruana.

Thank you for your help.
--A. B. (d) 17:34, 7 Settembru 2012 (UTC)